Jan 11, 2010

Potential Gotcha When Upgrading Spring MVC

After upgrading Spring and Spring MVC to version 2.5.6 (from a now-ancient 2.0.2), we started seeing some bizarre JavaScript errors for an otherwise-working application. This same problem may effect you.

The problem appeared when we had a form-backing object that held a list of child objects and some complex JavaScript for interacting with the form. Spring’s form tags starting at version 2.5 treat collections differently than in older versions, although this wasn’t apparent at first.

If you had a form-backing object with, say, a list of cars, you might have a form item in a JSP like the following:
<form:hidden path="cars[0].milesPerGallon" />
In prior versions of Spring MVC, this would output:
<input id="cars[0].milesPerGallon" name="cars[0].milesPerGallon" type="hidden" value="whatever" />
Note that the array-like syntax is necessary for binding the form data when the user submits the form.

(As an aside, setting the name and the ID to the same value causes problems in older versions of Internet Explorer.)

If you then accessed this element from JavaScript, you might have code like the following:
var elem = document.getElementById('cars[0].milesPerGallon');
After upgrading to Spring 2.5.x, though, the output differs:
<input id="cars0.milesPerGallon" name="cars[0].milesPerGallon" type="hidden" value="whatever" />
The ID attribute no longer sports square brackets. This change breaks the JavaScript code that expected a different ID. And, with JavaScript’s habit of silently failing, this proved difficult to track down, as you don’t expect a change in your Java libraries to suddenly break your JavaScript.

This change was not done to make the ID and name differ. Instead, square brackets are not allowed in IDs in HTML, as described in http://www.w3.org/TR/html4/types.html#type-name. Spring MVC was changed to correct the IDs. Oddly, you are not supposed to use square brackets in the name attribute either, but the form tags did not change the output of the name attribute.

See http://jira.springframework.org/browse/SPR-2380 and http://jira.springframework.org/browse/SPR-4698 for more on the explanation for the change in Spring MVC.

About the Author

Eric Foster-Johnson profile.

Eric Foster-Johnson

Principal Technologist

Eric has decades of industry experience in designing and developing complex enterprise software, including designing and developing Grails and Java EE solutions to tough client problems. He has experience leading development teams, mentoring developers, and helping troublesome projects get back onto a success track. He has lead teams in both traditional and agile settings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Blog Posts
Designing Kubernetes Controllers
There has been some excellent online discussion lately around Kubernetes controllers, highlighted by an excellent Speakerdeck presentation assembled by Tim Hockin. What I’d like to do in this post is explore some of the implications […]
React Server Components
The React Team recently announced new work they are doing on React Server Components, a new way of rendering React components. The goal is to create smaller bundle sizes, speed up render time, and prevent […]
Jolt custom java transform
Jolt is a JSON to JSON transformation library where the transform is defined in JSON. It’s really good at reorganizing the json data and massaging it into the output JSON you need. Sometimes, you just […]
Page Object Model for UI Testing